Frank Cafaro, founder of Cafaro Insurance Agency
738 Smithtown Bypass, Suite 110, Smithtown, NY
Phone : 631-321-6165 / Toll Free: 888-335-4233
cafaroins.com
In the world of insurance, finding a name you can trust is paramount—and for clients across Long Island and beyond, that name is Frank Cafaro. The founder of Cafaro Insurance Agency, Frank’s journey from a seasoned insurance agent to a leader in the industry spans more than three decades. Since launching the agency in 1991, Frank has built a reputation for reliability, dedication, and personalized service.
As the owner and heart of Cafaro Insurance, Frank specializes in a wide range of insurance services, including life insurance, commercial group health insurance, group disability, group dental, group vision and even specialized offerings like Buy-Sell and Key-Man life insurance. With accounts spread across New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, and Florida, his reach is vast—but his service remains deeply personal.
Frank’s deep roots in the insurance industry trace back to the late 1980s when he first started training other agents. He quickly became a familiar name across communities in Smithtown, Huntington, Hauppauge, Melville, and Farmingdale. From his earliest days in the business, Frank’s focus has always been on providing thoughtful, clear, and accessible guidance to clients, making the complicated world of insurance easier to navigate. He is known for his dedication to helping businesses and individuals find the right insurance coverage that not only fits their needs but also their budget.
What sets Cafaro Insurance Agency apart is Frank’s commitment to blending old-fashioned customer service with modern technology. While many businesses have embraced the convenience of automation and digital tools, Frank and his team at Cafaro Insurance understand that relationships and trust are still the cornerstone of success. With an impressive 95% client retention rate, Frank’s approach clearly resonates with clients who know they can rely on his expertise and personal attention to detail.
In fact, Frank’s first client, whom he still services today, is a testament to the enduring nature of the relationships he fosters. “It feels like I’ve known you forever,” is a sentiment shared by many of Frank’s clients, who not only value his knowledge but also his unwavering support.
For businesses, Cafaro Insurance Agency offers a comprehensive suite of employee benefits, including group medical insurance, group disability, group life, dental, and more. Whether you’re a small business or a larger enterprise, Cafaro Insurance provides tailored solutions that meet the diverse needs of your employees while simplifying the administrative process. On the individual side, Frank’s team helps clients navigate the often complex world of life insurance, Medicare supplement insurance, and other personal coverage options that provide peace of mind for individuals and families.
Cafaro Insurance Agency’s success isn’t just measured by its longevity or its broad client base. It’s the trust that clients place in Frank and his team, and the peace of mind that comes with knowing they have someone in their corner—someone who understands their unique needs and is committed to finding the right solution.
In a world where so much feels impersonal, Cafaro Insurance remains a true example of the power of one-on-one, client-first service. With Frank Cafaro at the helm, the agency continues to evolve, always staying ahead of the curve in a rapidly changing industry while staying true to its core values of trust, transparency, and dedication to customer satisfaction.
For anyone seeking insurance solutions that go beyond policies and forms, Cafaro Insurance Agency is the name you can count on—today and for many years to come.
20 lucky winners will win $500 each in prizes totaling $10,000. 